Mary was
related to the Tudors. Her grandmother was Margaret Tudor, Henry
VIII's older sister. Margaret Tudor had married King James V
of Scotland, and her son was Mary's father, James V. Henry VIII
was thus her great Uncle, and she and Elizabeth were cousins.
Henry VIII
wished to have baby Mary as a future bride for his infant son,
Edward, and in 1544, his forces invaded Scotland in an attempt
to force this matter, but he failed. Mary was sent to France
to marry the Dauphin, Francis, the eldest son of the king of
France, later Francis II. Her mother, Mary of Guise, acted as
regent in Scotland.
In 1559,
the King of France was killed in a jousting accident, and at
only seventeen years of age, Mary became Queen of France. This
alarmed Elizabeth, who had only just become Queen herself, as
she and her government feared that the French would now try
and claim the English throne as well. The French were simply
not in a position to do this, however. Mary of Guise's position
in Scotland was weak, and she was fighting for survival in a
country that was now Protestant. The French could not contemplate
attacking England when French rule in the country via Mary and
her French mother was so fragile. For this reason, Elizabeth's
ministers urged her to aid the Scots against their Catholic
government. Elizabeth was reluctant to aid rebels, but in the
name of self-preservation, agreed to some aid. English involvement
was rather disastrous, however, with the English forces suffering
humiliating defeat. William Cecil was sent to Scotland to negotiate
peace with the Scots, and he played a prominent part in drawing
up a treaty with the Scottish government, which guaranteed peace
between the two realms. The treaty of Edinburgh was never ratified
by Mary, however, as she refused to relinquish her claim to
the English throne that the English requested.
Mary was
always seen as a considerable threat to Elizabeth. Many Catholics
did not recognise Elizabeth as the true Queen of the realm.
They did not recognise the marriage of her mother, Anne Boleyn,
to her father, and so believed that she was illegitimate. Illegitimate
children were not supposed to become kings or queens. As well
as this, Elizabeth was also a Protestant, but Mary a Catholic.
For many years Catholics plotted to depose and kill Elizabeth
in order to put Mary on her throne. Mary herself did not recognise
Elizabeth as the true Queen, and believed that she herself was
the rightful Queen of England. Sometimes she even referred to
herself as such. The relationship between Mary and Elizabeth
was always very difficult. As mutual queens and cousins they
tried to keep up a pretence of friendship, but in reality they
did not like each other very much. Perhaps because she was nine
years older than Mary, Elizabeth always treated Mary with care,
and was remarkably tolerant of her less than respectful cousin.
In films and novels, Elizabeth is often made out to have been
very cruel to Mary, but this is not really true. There is a
tendency for people to side with one Queen over the other, but
it is better to treat them both as victims of the circumstances
in which they found themselves.
Not long
after, Francis died. No longer really welcome in France, Mary
soon returned to Scotland. Her return was much needed as her
mother, Mary of Guise, had died in the June of 1560. In the
August of 1561 Mary arrived at the port of Leith, and as only
a few people knew of her coming, she was greeted by only a few
of her lords. Because she was still refusing to sign the Treaty
of Edinburugh, Elizabeth denied her cousin passage through England,
and so Mary had bravely sailed the distance from Calais to Leith
directly. But the news of her arrival soon reached her people,
and they gathered in crowds to welcome the return of their long
absent sovereign.
Scotland
was very different to France, and Mary found her native country
rather disappointing. She had been away most of her life, and
had been brought up in wealth and splendour in France. Scotland
lacked France's wealth and glory, and it was also much colder.
The country was also Protestant. Mary tried her best to govern
Scotland well, and initially was successful. She was tolerant
of Protestants, listened to the advise given to her by her various
ministers, and kept at peace with her influential Protestant
half-brother, James Stewart, later Earl of Murray, illegitimate
son of her father, James V.
Now that
Mary was a widow, people were beginning to ask who she would
marry. As with Elizabeth, her marriage was of immense political
importance. It concerned the English government greatly. Elizabeth
feared that she would marry a very powerful prince who could
help her raise an army to invade England. Elizabeth wanted Mary
to marry a man with very little power or influence, so that
her Scottish cousin would be less of a threat. Perhaps with
this in mind, Elizabeth offered her Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester.
This was laughed as he was widely thought to be Elizabeth's
lover and a wife-murderer. Mary perceived it as an insult, although
it is unlikely that Elizabeth meant it to be. Elizabeth believed
that a marriage between them would guarantee the peace of both
realms. She believed that Dudley would never conspire against
her because of his affection for her, that he would fulfill
his ambitions, and Mary would have a husband, and eventually
with Elizabeth's blessing, be recognised as the heir to her
throne. This all made sense to Elizabeth, but the other people
involved in her plan had different ideas. Dudley was alarmed
at the thought of being cast off to Scotland, and did all that
he could to prevent the match, even reputedly writing to Mary
denying his interest in her hand. Mary at least pretended to
be sincere, but did not relish taking a man that her cousin
did not find good enough to make her own husband. In an attempt
to make Dudley more suitable for a Queen, Elizabeth raised him
to the nobility in 1564, making him Earl of Leicester and Baron
of Denbigh. Although Elizabeth appeared to be sincere in the
negotiations, many doubted that she really meant it, as she
and Dudley were so close that she could not bear for him to
even leave the court. Whatever Elizabeth's motives may have
been, the offer was made with all sincerity. Had Mary accepted
the offer, and Elizabeth agreed to it, Dudley would have found
resistance virtually impossible, but to his relief, the negotiations
fell through. Lord Henry Darnley, an English Catholic cousin
to Mary who also had a claim to the English crown, was permitted
by Elizabeth to travel with his father to Scotland, and Mary,
attracted by his person and position, decided to marry him.
Elizabeth was outraged. With their joint claim to her throne,
Elizabeth feared that they would have substantial support for
tryingto depose her. It also emerged that Darnley's mother,
Lady Lennox, had been involved in secret negotiations to have
Mary and Darnley placed upon the English throne. There was very
little Elizabeth could do, however, as Mary and Darnley were
legally married, and she had to accept him as Prince consort.
Elizabeth's consolation was the fact that matters could have
been much worse had Mary married a powerful European prince,
and Darnley in fact posed very little threat to her safety.
It was Mary's life that he made more miserable. Their marriage
was certainly not a happy one. Perhaps the only benefit of it,
was the birth of Mary's only son, James, in 1564. Darnley was
possessive, jealous, and a drunkard. He did not aid in the government
of the country at all, or make Mary's political life easier
- he only made it worse. Mary began to rely heavily on her Italian
Private Secretary, David Rizzio, who she liked and admired,
and Darnley grew jealous and angry. With a group of friends
he planned to murder him. One March night, 1566, while Rizzio,
who was a talented musician, was playing for Mary and her ladies,
Darnley and his men forced their way into the room. Rizzio clung
to Mary, but was dragged away, and murdered outside the door.
Mary, understandably, never forgave Darnley for this.
Mary now
turned more and more to one of her noble men, James Hepburn,
Fourth Earl of Bothwell. It was probably Bothwell that was largely
responsible for the eventual murder of Darnley. Darnley had
been ill with the small pox and was resting at The House at
Kirk O'Field. This house was blown to pieces, and Darnley's
dead body was soon found. But he did not die from the explosion,
it was found that he had actually been strangled. Mary was not
staying at the House at the time, although she was meant to
have been there, but decided to stay somewhere else. Mary declared
that the explosion was meant to kill her, but very few people
believed her. It was widely thought that she had connived with
Bothwell to murder her husband. Bothwell and Mary had been close
for some time, and despite the public outcry against him following
Darnley's death, Mary married him very soon after. This was
the beginning of the end of her reign in Scotland. Her people
were outraged that she had married the man suspected of murdering
her husband. In the streets they called her all sorts of names,
and soon people were calling for her abdication as monarch.
Mary's army met that of her enemies at Carberry Hill, but when
she saw the magnitude of the opposition, she surrendered without
even putting up a fight. She was taken as a prisoner to Loch
Leven Castle. Against her will she was coerced to sign the abdication
papers. From that moment onwards, her infant son was King James
VI of Scotland. Her half-brother James Stewart, Earl of Murray,
became regent. He did not long survive, however, as he was assassinated
in 1570 by one of Mary's supporters.
After a
few months, a careful plan was made to free her. She was guided
out of the castle by a sixteen year old page, Willie Douglas,
and they secretly made their way to the lake. She was rowed
across the lake, and on the other side, friends waited to meet
her. Mary was provided with a horse, and rode for her life and
freedom. She then rose another army, but was defeated at the
Battle of Langside.
Mary helplessly
fled to England. She had few friends and many enemies, and even
her European supporters had turned against her. She beseeched
Elizabeth to help her. This was a very difficult time for Elizabeth.
She had always feared Mary's power and influence, but the deposition
and disgrace of a fellow monarch frightened her more. If they
could treat one Queen like this, then they could so easily treat
another one that way too. Elizabeth took Mary under her protection,
but in reality she was little more than a prisoner. For the
rest of her life, this is what she became. Mary was kept in
various Castles in England for nineteen years - including Sheffield
for fourteen years, Bolton, Wakefield, and Tutbury. In 1570,
she obtained a divorce from Bothwell, and he died insane in
aprioson in the Netherlands in 1578. Many people wanted Mary
dead, but Elizabeth would not hear of executing her cousin and
fellow monarch, and refused all requests of releasing her so
that her enemies could kill her. Mary owed her life to Elizabeth,
but still the relationship between the two Queens was difficult,
perhaps more than it had ever been. Mary soon resented being
kept a captive in England, and longed to be restored to the
Scottish throne, and gain the English. She was placed in the
care of George Herbert, Earl of Shrewsbury, and was watched
carefully by the Elizabethan government who feared that she
would become the focus of Catholic plots. Their fears were not
unfounded. For the next twenty years there were attempts to
release Mary from her prison and make her Queen of England.
Elizabeth's councillors continued to urge her to have the Scottish
Queen executed, but Elizabeth resisted them. It was not until
the Babington plot of 1586 that she finally relented, and only
then because there was proof of Mary's complicity. Elizabeth
was hurt and angry that Mary had personally endorsed her murder,
when for almost twenty years, she had protected Mary's life.
She wrote a letter to Mary to this effect. It was the plan of
Sir Anthony Babington and his co-conspirators to release Mary
from the House at Chartely where she was kept, and to depose
and kill Elizabeth. Their plans failed, however, as Sir Francis
Walsingham, one of Elizabeth's most influential ministers, had
created a very effective spy-network, that monitored the actions
of English Catholics by using double agents and spies. Anthony
Babington and his supporters were tortured and put to death,
and Mary was put on trial. She was found guilty of treason,
and condemned to death. But despite this judgment by Elizabeth's
judges, Elizabeth could not bring herself to sign her cousin's
death warrant. The very thought of executing a crowned sovereign
terrified her, and the whole matter effected her health profoundly.
In the end she reluctantly signed the warrant. Her ministers
secretly rushed through the execution, and Elizabeth was not
told until it was over. Mary was executed at Fotheringay Castle
in the February of 1587.
Elizabeth's
fury was tremendous. She had her Private secretary, William
Davidson, arrested, and turned against those of her Council
who had taken part in the execution, even her old trusted servant,
William Cecil. She threatened to have Davidson hanged, saying
that she never intended the execution to take place, only to
use the warrant as a threat to stop Mary from taking part in
such activities again. No one really believed her, and few have
believed her since. Frightening as it was, her anger receded,
and in time she was reunited with Cecil. Davidson was released
from imprisonment, but was never returned to his post as secretary.
Mary was
buried in Peterborough Cathedral, but was moved to Westminster
Abbey in 1612. In life, Mary and Elizabeth never met, but in
death, they lie only feet away from each other in perhaps the
greatest of English Abbeys.
Mary was
a gifted woman, and reputedly very tall, elegant and beautiful,
but in the often bitter struggle for power between her and Elizabeth,
Mary lost because unlike her English cousin, she let her heart
rule her head, sacrificing politics for passion. After Amy Dudley's
mysterious death, which many put down to her husband, Robert
Dudley, Elizabeth knew that marrying the man she undoubtedly
loved would be political death. In contrast, when Bothwell was
publicly regarded as the murderer of Mary's husband, and her
people were incensed against him, Mary ignored all advice to
distance herself from the man reputed to be her lover, and married
him. But tragic and misguided as her short life was, Mary has
left her legacy to history, and following Elizabeth's death
in 1603, her son was proclaimed King of England, and his accession
brought a new dynasty to the English throne - the Stuarts.